Huge cod cuts devastate historic fleet,sending fishery into uncharted waters
NMFS is offering quota carryovers, more opportunity to harvest monkfish and to pick up the tab for at-sea monitoring costs. But it looks like little can ease New England groundfishermen's final reckoning with Gulf of Maine cod stocks.
The 77 percent reduction that begins May 1 will finally put many boats out of business, industry and outside observers say. Classic economic theory suggests that survivors should receive higher prices. But the industry is in uncharted waters now.
Climate-driven changes that stymied managers' recovery plans are now affecting catchability, too, and flipping availability and pricing of fish. New England cod prices at auction averaged $2 to $2.40 a pound in early February, but haddock averaged around $3.40 — nearly twice the price it was one year before.
The price inversion is happening because haddock "is harder to find. They are much more temperature sensitive... The fishermen say it's harder to locate it now," says Jenny Sun, senior marine resource economist at the Gulf of Maine Research Institute in Portland, Maine. That suggests "the haddock may be following the same trend" as cod, she says.
Gulf of Maine cod are just at 20 percent of the population level they need to be sustainably fished, and the Georges Bank stock is even worse at just 7 percent, according to John Bullard, NMFS' Northeast regional director.
In summer 2012, Bullard began breaking the bad news that environmental factors like climate change had outflanked government managers and scientists. The stocks aren't coming back, he admitted, despite years of catch reductions and the agency's big bet on catch shares as a long-term solution.
Bullard said NMFS would allow some carry-over of unused 2012 fish quotas into 2013, up to 10 percent in some areas but not in the Gulf of Maine. That raised complaints from the Conservation Law Foundation, which insists nothing less than a full shutdown of the fishery can save cod.
On March 1 at the Maine Fishermen's Forum, NMFS announced it planned to shift its budget around to cover $6.7 million in groundfish observer costs, to spare the industry from paying it this year. But it was not at all clear that the decision will survive the federal budget sequester and its mandatory cuts.
NMFS also offered an emergency six-month suspension of monkfish possession limits in New England, a move the agency says will nudge landings up a few percent and add about $740,000 in revenue to the region. It's one of the few stocks left with reliable supply and domestic and export demand that keeps ex-vessel prices between $3 and $4.
Elsewhere cod is doing well for fishermen in Iceland and Norway, where growth in the Barents Sea cod fishery led the industry Groundfish Forum to predict the overall Atlantic cod supply will increase 18 percent in 2013. Seafood.com Editor John Sackton went so far as to predict cod landed on other Atlantic shores could be poised, like salmon, to capture a bigger share of the everyday consumer protein market this year.
As the scale of this year's cod cuts was sinking in, NMFS at the end of 2012 issued a report saying Northeast groundfish vessel revenues in 2011 had been the best in three years, up more than 10 percent to almost $331 million, while fleet consolidation appeared to slow at around 800 vessels.
That process seems certain to accelerate in the other direction, as more fishermen without adequate catch share try to sell and get out. The final insult: Congress failing to approve a $150 million fisheries disaster aid that was tied to a $60 billion package for Hurricane Sandy.
"There are only repeated, record reductions in catch limits," said an open letter to Congress seeking emergency aid that 173 New England fishermen signed. "Prosperity is a discarded dream. This is a real disaster." — Kirk Moore
Alaska & Pacific Sardines and P-cod
Industry stuck with sardine survey data; P-cod vying with big Barents Sea quota
The Pacific Fishery Management Council's decision to reduce the sardine harvest quota from 2012's 94,000 metric tons to 66,495 metric tons spotlights problems the industry has with the acoustical and aerial survey data used to determine biomass for 2013.
"It took a major tumble," says Diane Pleschner-Steele, executive director of the California Wetfish Producers Association, in Buellton, Calif.
Fisheries scientists consider many variables in assessing sardine populations, among them hydroacoustic and aerial surveys, as well as point sets — catch samples used to extrapolate school density. Aerial surveys taken in 2012 indicated the biomass was 906,680 metric tons.
The point sets help validate the aerial survey data. However, Pleschner-Steele says, only 14 acceptable point sets could be made in the time available — too few for validation. Hence, point set and aerial survey data between 2008 and 2012 were pooled and averaged out. As a result, the biomass survey estimate was lowered to 696,251 metric tons.
The industry also questions the hydroacoustic surveys done in the Pacific Northwest. Those surveys, Pleschner-Steele says, indicated that the total biomass was just 14,000 metric tons. Yet sardine harvesters were landing nearly 50,000 metric tons from the same area and at the same time the surveys were conducted, she says.
One problem, Pleschner-Steele says, is that the transducers mounted on boats conducting the hydroacoustic surveys look straight down and don't see what's off to the sides of the boat.
"The way the transducer is mounted, they're missing the top 10 meters of the water column," she says. "The fish move to the side of the boat, and they're missing them."
While a total re-evaluation of stock assessment models will be up for consideration in 2014, the criteria underpinning this year's quota come from the formula the council adopted in 2011.
"They're not allowed to change anything," Pleschner-Steele says of the criteria used the past two years. "They're basically turning the crank on the same model, and we're stuck with what we've got."
If this year's fishing pace matches last year's, the fleet can expect heavy landings. Last year during the second harvest period running from July 1 to Sept. 14, seiners landed almost 52,000 metric tons, most of which came from Oregon and Washington.
"The guys up in the Northwest were locked and loaded," Pleschner-Steele says. "They did really well."
The 2012 West Coast harvest totaled 100,206 metric tons worth $21.2 million, according to Pacific Fisheries Information Network data. That's up considerably from the 2011 totals of 46,745 metric tons valued at $9.7 million. This year ex-vessel prices, as they did in 2012, are tracking at $200 per ton.
In the Pacific cod fishery, Bering Sea trawlers, longliners and pot fishermen will work on a quota of 262,900 metric tons, up slightly from 2012's 261,000 metric tons. In the Gulf of Alaska, the fleet went after 68,250 metric tons, up from 65,700 in 2012.
Of significant consideration this year is how extra volumes of Atlantic cod from the Barents Sea will affect world markets. Norway's Ministry of Fisheries and Coastal Affairs announced a 2013 shared quota (between Norway and Russia) of 1 million metric tons late last year.
That's a 249,000 metric ton jump from the 2012 quota, leaving the Alaska industry to wonder how the extra production will affect markets in general, particularly in market sectors trading headed and gutted cod.
The surge of frozen products — and the ensuing ex-vessel price drop — affected Homer pot fishermen in February, when amid stormy weather they got 30 cents per pound for their deliveries. Moreover, fishing was spotty during the smaller tides of the month.
"We're 10 cents down from last year," says Glen Carroll, who owns two cod boats that fish out of Homer. "Against the backdrop of last year" — one of Carroll's best ever in terms of catch and prices — "it seems dismal."
— Charlie Ess
National Fisherman Live: 1/27/15
In this episode:
Assessment: Atlantic menhaden is not overfished
Bering Sea pollock fishery casts off
Dock to Dish opens Florida’s first CSF
Second wave of disaster funds for Alaska
Fisherman lands N.C.’s largest bluefin ever
The Alaska Seafood Marketing Institute is still seeking public review and comment on the Alaska Responsible Fisheries Management Conformance Criteria (Version 1.2, September 2011). The public review and comment period, which opened on Dec. 3, 2014, runs through Monday, Feb. 3.
NOAA, in consultation with the Department of the Interior, has appointed 10 new members to the Marine Protected Areas Federal Advisory Committee. The 20-member committee is composed of individuals with diverse backgrounds and experience who advise the departments of commerce and the interior on ways to strengthen and connect the nation's MPA programs. The new members join the 10 continuing members appointed in 2012.